Cache.deals Videos
Ask Ian: Why Not a Semiauto BAR Instead of the Garand?

Ask Ian: Why Not a Semiauto BAR Instead of the Garand?

66
Published on July 26, 2022
Duration: 8:19

This video delves into a historical firearms design question: why did the US military opt for the M1 Garand over a semi-automatic development of the BAR (Browning Automatic Rifle)? The explanation highlights key rejection factors for a BAR-based design in 1919, including its lack of manual operation capability in case of malfunction, its excessive weight, and its inability to be clip-fed. Further requirements from the 1921 RFP for a new US Army semi-automatic rifle are discussed, such as a strict 9.5-pound weight limit and a preference for clip-fed systems holding 5-10 rounds, illustrating the military's reasoning against magazine-fed designs and the BAR's significant weight reduction challenges.

Watch on YouTube

More Firearms Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →

Trending in Firearms Reviews

View all →